The exercise of Comparison involves the juxtaposition of two subjects side by side, showing one to be better than the other (double encomium), one to be worse than the other (double invective), or one to be good and the other bad (encomium combined with invective).
Praise two people (or things) in close comparison, or praise one and condemn the other (you may use the persons you confirmed and vituperated against in the last exercises). Be certain not to treat them separately, but together, in parallel fashion. After composing an exordium (introduction), follow these steps (examples are on p. 408-412):
1. Describe the stock each person comes from:
* what people
* what country
* what ancestors
* what parents
2. Describe each person's upbringing
* education
* instruction in art
* training in laws
3. Describe each person's deeds, which should be described as the results of
* his/her excellencies or evils of mind (such as fortitude/weakness or prudence/indiscretion)
* his/her excellencies or evils of body (such as beauty/plainness, speed/lethargy, or vigor/lack of vigor)
* his/her excellencies or evils of fortune (good/ill use of high position, power, wealth, or friends)
4. Conclude with an epilogue including an exhortation to your hearers to/not to emulate either person
When it comes to mixed martial arts, there are typically two types of fighters: those who want to take it to the ground (“ground and pound”) and those who want to stand and strike toe to toe. Georges “Rush” Saint-Pierre and Matt “The Terra” Serra are anything but typical.
Matt Serra is seven years older than George Saint-Pierre or GSP. While Serra was born and grew up in Long Island, New York, GSP was born and raised in Saint-Isidore, Quebec, Canada, and it’s obvious when you hear them speak. Both of the fighters began to study martial arts in order to combat the dangers and bullies that plauged their childhood. It seems the young French-Canadian had many of the same problems a young New Yorker had growing up.
Though Serra first started studying kung fu, he soon began studying Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu under the renowned master Renzo Gracie. GSP also studied under Renzo Gracie in New York, but the two never crossed paths due to their difference in age. Serra earned his black belt in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu in 2000 under Renzo, thus becoming the first American to do so. However, not far behind, GSP earned his brown belt (a step lower) from Renzo in 2006. Two call these two men some of the most well-versed Jiu-Jitsu in the world wouldn’t be incorrect, it would just leave a lot out. Both fighters are incredibly dangerous if the fight stands up and striking becomes the means to a knockout. Matt Serra has been studying boxing and Mau Thai in two gyms that he owns with his brother in New York. This serves as a great compliment to his amazing ground game. In the same vain, GSP has been working on his boxing at the Grant Brothers Gym in Quebec, allowing him the luxury of boxing with world champion Joachim Alcine. GSP even recently began training at a renowned fighting school in the elevation of the mountains in New Mexico to strengthen his cardio.
Overall, Serra’s record is nine wins with four losses, while GSP’s record is 15 wins with only two losses. GSP has defeated a who’s who list of fighters from around the world, but one of his two losses came on April 7th of 2007 to none other than Matt Serra in the first round in order to make Serra the UFC World Welterweight Champion. On April 19th GSP gets his chance to avenge his first round embarrassment at the hands of Serra and regain the championship he lost.
While GSP has the advantage of being seven years younger and four inches taller, Serra has the experience and the fact that he knows that knocked this guy out just about a year ago. Both are incredible fighters, and their work eithic, level of skill, and desire for success ought to be revered by all. Fortunately in this sport, we don't have to debate or speculate for long about who's better in a comparison because they do it for us when they go mano y mano. They're two great men, may the best man win.