Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 22:10 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "I became dedicated to making our book the best it could be after attending Columbia Scholastic Press conference in New York City my junior year."

Modify Remove


Mary,

I really enjoyed reading your paper. I think your artwork is beautiful and considering I have absolutely no artistic talent whatsoever (I screw up stick figures), you're my artistic hero :o) You convey your ideas and your thoughts very clearly; you stay focused throughout the paper and everything you say, every example is well-placed. Your progression from childhood throughout high-school, up to today showing how your passion has evolved strengthens your paper and brings cohesion.

However, I feel like sometimes your tone gets a little colloquial--watch the contractions. Also, I think you could expound a little more on how you could see your passion shaping your future, if you've even thought about that yet. Also, there seems to be an abrupt break between your description of your passion and how you see it today (when you started talking about college apps). Try to add some transition to help the paper flow.

Revision:
"I became dedicated to making our book the best it could be after attending Columbia Scholastic Press conference in New York City my junior year."

Just a little wordy and could be made more succint.

Suggestion: After attending the Columbia Scholastic Press Conference in New York city in my junior year, I became dedicated to creating the best possible book.

Overall, well written and organized.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Tue Nov 14 2006 10:01 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "Today, I relish the fact that I can name all 9 members of the West Coast gangster rap group The Wu-Tang Clan as well as recommend a fantastic Swedish yodeling record."

Modify Remove


Brad!

Your paper was by far the most fun to read! I think everything we read needs to have a prescribed soundtrack to set the mood! I always look forward to seeing in what new creative way you're going to surprise us all. The songs you have chosen to accompany each section of your paper are very apprpropriate and enhance the paper at a different level to make the whole "paper-reading experience" more enjoyable and tolerable. I like how honest you are about your feelings towards music and how your love has grown and progressed throughout the years. I think your struggle with how your passion fits into your future is one that many can associate with and that helps engage the reader.

Although the more casual, colloquial tone is more your style, I don't know how appropriate it is for a formal paper. Watch the contractions and I think you could try to make your sentences and style less conversational and more formal with varied sentence structure, word choice, and overal grammar. Also, to show that music truly is what you love, I think you should try to expound more on why music, in itself, is what you love, instead of just talking about...like explain more as to why music, of all things, is your passion. Finally, maybe try to spend some time exploring ways in which music does fit into your future and how you can continue to evolve this passion.

Revision:
"Today, I relish the fact that I can name all 9 members of the West Coast gangster rap group The Wu-Tang Clan as well as recommend a fantastic Swedish yodeling record."

I don't think the word "relish" is used appropriately here (check Bump's favorite OED).

Suggestion: Today, I take pride in the fact that I can name each of the nine members of the West Coast rap group, The Wu Tang Clan, as well as recommend a fantastic Swedish Yodeling record.

Overall, your paper is written openly and invites the reader to share your passion. Just clean it up with revision and try to expand.

 

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 22:30 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "The painter is looking inward as he tries to find such an image, and as the observer analyzes the image he draws connections between what he believes is the intention of the painting, the context of the painting, and what the painting inspires in his own

Modify Remove


Ashley,

I enjoyed reading your paper about art, itself, and how and why it is your passion. I almost envy you because you've realized what you love so early on--even if you don't quite know what you want to do with rest of your life, you know what you love, what makes you happy, and that, in itself, is something so many of us constantly strive to realize. Your paper is very solid, stays focused throughout, and is well organized. I like the beginning, where you set up where your love for art originated--it helps strenghen your paper and add clarity.

Although your explanation of what you love about art helps explain why art is your passion, I feel like you spend too much time talking about art itself. Don't forget that this paper is a narrative, not a thesis about a specific topic...if that makes sense. Just be sure stay focused as to how the passion relates to you. Oh and maybe you could incorporate how you see art fitting into your future, if you've thought that far.

Revision:
"The painter is looking inward as he tries to find such an image, and as the observer analyzes the image he draws connections between what he believes is the intention of the painting, the context of the painting, and what the painting inspires in his own mind."

This sentence is wordy and confusing.

Suggestion: The painter searches for such an imagine within, while the observer draws connections and conclusions based on the context of the painting, the intention of the painting, and what the painting inspires in his own mind.

Well-written with clarity and focus.

Post reply

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 23:02 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "As I spent the first few weeks working at the two schools, my two kids grew warmer with me and it was not long before they were comfortable with me."

Modify Remove


Mauro,

Your paper genuinely made me smile :o) You are incredibly selfless and we need more people like you in the world! Your examples as to why you care so much about making others happy help to strenghen your paper. Also, the way you present your paper in such a non-pretentious way helps add clarity.

However, I feel like many of your thoughts and ideas are very disparate and just don't seem to flow throughout your paper. Try to make more connections between examples and ideas. The way you switched between how happy it made you making others happy and then how distrusting you became of others seems very disjoint and leads to confusion. Also, your tone is a little too colloquial for my taste, but you insert random bits of formality that seems awkward. Overall, just try to add more transition throughout the paper, the sentences, and the ideas to help the paper flow better.

Revision:
"As I spent the first few weeks working at the two schools, my two kids grew warmer with me and it was not long before they were comfortable with me."

This sentence structure and word choice makes the sentence a little awkward.

Suggestion: As I spent more time working at the two schools, my students slowly warmed up to me and eventually became entirely comfortable with me.

Overall, great idea, just revise for focus.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 23:17 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "When I was a little girl I would daily gather all my dolls and Barbies with my friends and go on an adventure in the park as a house mom, or in the hospital as a doctor, or in a space shuttle as an astronaut. "

Modify Remove


Pallavi,

Your paper definitely illustrates how important making a difference in the world is to you, as cliche as it sounds. I like how you introduced the paper by starting with your love for helping in childhood and tracking the evoluntion and progression of your passion throughout the paper. Also, the example about debate and your awareness of the world is a good way to distinguish that you want to make the world better in whatever way possible, not necessarily as a doctor.

However, I feel like your paper lacks focus; you seem to talk about a lot of different passions, not just helping. You describe your desire to help, your love for learning, and your desire to make a difference, but I am unable to figure out which is focus of your paper. I think you need to either explore your different passions at the beginning, then pick one to elaborate on or just stick with one throughout.

Revision:
"When I was a little girl I would daily gather all my dolls and Barbies with my friends and go on an adventure in the park as a house mom, or in the hospital as a doctor, or in a space shuttle as an astronaut. "

The word choice and word placement is a little awkward, making the sentence confusing.

Suggestion: As a child, my friends and I would gather our dolls and Barbies everyday and go on an adventure, sometimes as house mom in the park, or as a doctor in a hospital, or as an astronaut in a space shuttle.

Overall, your desire to make a difference is solid, just try to focus on one way to do this.

Post reply

Forum: Project Two Date: Tue Nov 14 2006 19:10 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "While I was there, I witnessed a protest against teacher salary laws, I was amazed that the children experience endless enjoyment from a simple toy called ¿clackers,¿ and I discovered a culture that embraced each person so fully that coming back to"

Modify Remove


Rachel!

Your creativity and inspiration never ceases to amaze me. I always look forward to reading your papers and DBRs because you explore ideas untouched and always discover suprise me with some new conclusion that I never considered. Your paper is unique, to say the least, but the manner in which you presented it is so clear and focused that it has no awkwardness and flows well. The introduction is a great way to enage the reader and invite us to consider something as mundane as emotion from an entirely different perspective. Also, the anecdote from
Honduras supports and clarifies your thesis.

Although you present your ideas and thoughts well, I feel like it stops there; I think you should try to elaborate more on what exactly this search for "pure emotion" means to you, not just how it doesn't exist in American society. On that note, I felt like you spent too much time talking about American culture and criticizing the lack of emotion in society. Instead, focus more on the meaning of your passion and how it affects you and how it plays a role (and will play a role) in your life, now and in the future. Also, the second to last paragraph, when you briefly mention art, seems out of place and unnecessary. I would suggest either taking it out or expanding it more.

Revision:
"While I was there, I witnessed a protest against teacher salary laws, I was amazed that the children experience endless enjoyment from a simple toy called ¿clackers,¿ and I discovered a culture that embraced each person so fully that coming back to
America after only one week away was a major culture shock."

This sentence is waaay too long and you introduce too many different ideas leading to confusion--try breaking it up or just rearranging the sentence.

Suggestion: While I was there, I discovered a society that was like nothing I had ever known; as a result, I experienced a major culture shock upon returning to
America. For example, a protest against teacher salaries ensued, children experienced endless enjoyment from a simple toy called "clackers", and the Honduran culture embraced each individual more fully than any other culture I had seen.

Overall, great paper, just revise with a fine tooth comb for minor details.

Post replyPost reply

Forum: Project Two Date: Tue Nov 14 2006 19:31 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "My teammate Rachel took the kick and I felt like time stopped. I watched the ball take flight in an arch-like motion until it reached its apex."

ModifyModify RemoveRemove


Prianka!

You are so lucky to have found not only what you're good at, but more importantly, what you love, what truly makes you happy. :o) Your paper definitely illustrates your love for the sport, especially the one at the end about the team camaraderie. I really like the way you expressed so much of your emootion in the paper--it helps the reader relate to what is such a big part of your life. I love all the descriptions about the games; they provide beautiful imagery for the reader to understand you and your love for soccer.

However, I feel like overall, your paper is very disparate: each paragraph seems somewhat disjoint from the others. If you just add some transition sentences and try to connect ideas more clearly, I think your paper will flow better. Your tone is also a little colloquial at times. I understand that sometimes you were trying to convey what you were feeling and what was going through your mind at the time, but it comes across too choppy and abrupt. I would suggest italicizing your "thoughts" to make it clear the the reader that this is what's going through your mind. Also, parts of your paper seem abrupt due to the number of short, choppy sentences. Just vary sentence structure and length and that should help with fluidity. Finally, I would suggest spending less time talking abut soccer itself and although the anecdotes help strengthen your paper, I think you could focus more of the paper on why soccer is your passion (what it brings to your life, how it makes you feel, etc, etc) and how it could play a role in your future.

Revision:
"My teammate Rachel took the kick and I felt like time stopped. I watched the ball take flight in an arch-like motion until it reached its apex."

I think these sentences can be combined and the structure can be rearranged for a more fluid sentence.

Suggestion: Time seemingly stopped as my teammate Rachel took the kick: the ball soared through the air until it reached its apex and....<--you can even continue to describe the ball here.

Overall, your passion is clear and focused and with some revision adding transitions, it will help the paper flow.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Wed Nov 15 2006 11:47 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "In creating the two posters shown here, I had great experiences. It was incredibly fun to be behind the camera at my own photo shoot, capturing the actors and directing them on how I wanted them to look"

Modify Remove


Liz, my lovely,

I love how passionate you are about discovering love in every apsect of life :o) Love truly is the single thread that weaves all humans and all facets of life together and I think that through it, you will discover your pilgrammage, whatever that may be. Ok, now that I'm done with the sentimentalness, contrary to what you my think, your essay was not disparate or disconnect, for the most part. You successfully relate the first few paragraphs by ending each one with a comment as to how they are all connected through love. Also, your personal anecdotes for how you incorporate the different types of beauty into your life strenghen your paper.

Although your voice shines through the paper, I feel like it's a bit too colloquial; I can tell that you wrote the paper straight from your thoughts, which is a very honest, open way to engage the reader, but sometimes it felt a little abrupt, which affected the overall flow of the paper. Also, you often stated things very blatantly: as in, "One of my other passions" or "This relates to that". If you try to vary sentence structure, combine sentences and thoughts, and add more transitions, your paper should flow beautifully. I thought that everything was fitting together quite nicely--with love connecting each of your passions--but towards the end, when you started discussing politics and science, I got confused: what do politics have to do with a passion for love? I would suggest either somehow relating politcs and science by explaining how they are also an expression of love, or just cutting it out. Finally, you have great examples, but I would suggest maybe incorporating thoughts, feelings, and ideas as to how your passion for love and expressions of beauty affect you and how they might be incorporated into your future.

Revision:
"In creating the two posters shown here, I had great experiences. It was incredibly fun to be behind the camera at my own photo shoot, capturing the actors and directing them on how I wanted them to look"

Here is an example of when you say something very plainly and abruptly. Try combining for fluidity.

Suggestion: When I created these two posters shown below, I was given the opportunity to express my own vision of beauty by directing the actors and the shoot from behind the camera.

Overall, your paper has solid ideas and your passion is clear for the most part. Just work on revivision to add flow and connect each of your thoughts.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Tue Nov 14 2006 10:14 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "Instead of running to retrieve an adult, I held my little brother, staring at him blankly while he continued to bleed. I must have expected someone else to help him."

ModifyModify RemoveRemove


Law,

Your paper is well-written and now I understand what you were talking about by a formatting the paper as your pilgrammage to realization. It definitely sets up an easy method of organization that leads to clarity and a focus. I really like the way that you build up to your final goal by describing your progression and realization of your passion; it helps to strengthen why helping people is your passion.

However, I feel like you spend a little bit too long talking about self-actualization and giving background for your passion. I think you could condense that information and you should actually discuss your passion of helping people more--make it the main focus if your paper. Also, be sure to talk about why it is your passion and how helping people relates to you, in your life. Finally, parts of your paper sounds very abrupt because you have many short, choppy sentences. Try to vary sentence structure and combine sentences and thoughts to create a better flow throughout your paper.

Revision:
"Instead of running to retrieve an adult, I held my little brother, staring at him blankly while he continued to bleed. I must have expected someone else to help him."

I think these two sentences can be combined and some of the word choice is a little awkward.

Suggestion: Instead of retrieving an adult, I stared blankly at my little brother,helplessly holding him in my arms, perhaps expecting someone else to help him.

Overall, the paper is well-written. Just revise it for fluidity and be sure to remember the focus of this paper.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Tue Nov 14 2006 12:50 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "Likewise, people that are only book smart find it difficult to perform in a people-oriented society."

Modify Remove


Emily,

Well, you definitely sound like a Plan II student: knowledgable, (com)passionate, and undecided! I like the way you developed your paper by introducing your love for knowledge and your natural compassion, but recognizing that neither is enough in its own realm. You have quite a few personal anecdotes that help personify your paper and allow the audience to take a glimpse into your life, while also helping the audience to relate to what you're saying.

However, I feel like you spend too long describing what kind of person you are, like you're justifying the your love of learning and your compassion in life. I think you should try to be more progression throughout your paper and introduce more ideas, more thoughts, and explore your future more, rather than spend so much time explaining yourself. Also, some of your quotes (especially in the first paragraph) are awkwardly placed; maybe you should reconsider your choice of quotes because it seems like you have to add quite a bit in brackets to add clarity. Finally, I was a little confused by your organization of the paper; try breaking up paragraphs and ideas to add clarity.

Revision:
"Likewise, people that are only book smart find it difficult to perform in a people-oriented society."

This sentence is a little wordy and can be clarified with better word choice.

Suggestion: Likewise, those who possess solely book knowledge often feel out of place and uncomfortable in society.

Overall, solid ideas, just revise and elaborate.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Tue Nov 14 2006 13:22 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "So because of everything football taught me and the fact that I absolutely loved every minute of it, I consider playing football a passion of mine.'

Modify Remove


Garrison!

Well, I definitely consider football in a different light now--not just a bunch of sweaty guys butting heads! Your descriptions provide great imagery for the reader and truly depict why football (or the bonds from football) mean so much to you. I like the way you introduce your passion by giving a background as to how it developed and what instigated you to realize your passion for friendship.

However, I feel like you spend more time talking about football, itself, and how much it means to you, rather than your passion for friendship. Be sure to focus on one or the other; if you use football to introduce your passion, then make sure it is just to lead into your paper about your true passion, whatever that may be. Also, I think you should discuss the friendship aspect more as to why it means so much to you and the how a meaningful relationship affects you.

Revision:
"So because of everything football taught me and the fact that I absolutely loved every minute of it, I consider playing football a passion of mine."

This sentence is a little wordy and can be clarified with different sentence structure.

Suggestion: My love for football and everything I learned from playing the sport helped me realize that it is one of my many passions in life.

Overall, solid idea, just expand your actual passion and revise for grammatical errors.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Tue Nov 14 2006 13:44 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "I had always thought that my career track would be getting a degree in biology, attending medical school to get my MD, and then it would be a straight shot to becoming a successful pediatrician."

Modify Remove


Alex,

In all honesty, I became so frustrated the first I read your paper because you so clearly and coherently depicted everything I feel like I'm trying to say and all of my similar frustrations! (Take that as a compliment!) Your essay is very well-written, with a mature tone, and a clear focus. The honesty with which you write, describing your fears, doubts, and insecurities, gives the reader a glimpse into your psyche, and helps the reader relate to you and your struggles. Your voice shines through the words throughout the paper and really gives the paper character.

However, I often felt like your tone became a little pretentious. Sometimes your thoughts and they manner in which you conveyed them came across somewhat bombastic, almost hostile towards a society that you see as so uncaring and superficial. (By the way, I completely understand your point of view and agree with it, just try not to be so harsh in your paper). Also, you seemed to waver between your dream of becoming a doctor and your passion for compassion; I understand that that, in itself, is your struggle, but maybe consider introducing by describing your conflicts, but focusing the paper on a single passion. Finally, maybe elaborate on your personal anecdotes that illustrate your "passion for compassion" instead of just saying it--show it, don's just state it; this will help strengthen your paper and your point.

Reivision:
"I had always thought that my career track would be getting a degree in biology, attending medical school to get my MD, and then it would be a straight shot to becoming a successful pediatrician."

The verb choice sounds a little awkward and the sentence structure is a little unclear; if you're going to med school, you're obviously getting your MD--no need to state that.

Suggestion: I have always expected that I would attain a degree in biology, attend medical school, and continue on the path to becoming a successful pediatrician.

Overall, well-written and solid foundation from which to elaborate. Just revise with a fine tooth comb for minor details.

Post reply

Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 18:31 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "My compassion for others comes from my mother. The way she carries herself and the way she lives her life has been an inspirational example to me."

Modify Remove


Eric,

Your paper is off to a great start. You have a lot of ideas and examples that help illustrate how your passion developed. I really liked that your explained how your passion evolved, from your realization of how blessed you are. You're right in that many Americans have no idea how lucky they are to live the life they do.

However, I feel like some of your ideas are a little disparate. Work on fludity throughout the paper with transitions. Also, for many of your examples, you take a long time to get to the point; as in, you describe every miniscule detail in every single example which leads to wordiness. And many of your sentences are short and choppy; try to connect more thoughts, ideas, and sentences so that the paper is not so abrupt. Finally, I felt like your introduction was also abrupt; maybe ease into the thought with something else to introduce the paper instead of immediately talking about your parents and your life.

Revision:
"My compassion for others comes from my mother. The way she carries herself and the way she lives her life has been an inspirational example to me."

I think these two sentences can be connected to change up sentence structure and add fluidity.

Suggestion: The manner in which my mother carries herself and they way she lives her life has always inspired me.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 18:06 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "The agony of believing that if your parents knew who you really were they you would be disowned is utterly overwhelming."

Modify Remove


Trevor!

I love your paper!!! You have written this paper with such passion and brutal honesty that I really felt for you as you were describing how much you have struggled. You have written this from your heart and it realy shines through the words, strengthening your paper. I really liked the way your struggles and your experiences is the continous thread throughout the paper--it's a great way to always remind the reader why it is your passion.

However, some ideas are a little disconnect; you sometimes introduce an idea or a thought about society or yourself and leave it hanging. Just be sure to expound and elaborate if you bring something up. Also, I think you spend a lot of time explaining yourself and kind of defending why it is your passion. Try to maybe talk more about what you plan to do about the issue and be careful not to turn it into a paper about homosexual rights: it is a personal narrative, not a thesis on a topic...if that makes sense. Finally, be sure to revise with a fine tooth comb--you kind of forget words here and there and make some mistakes that spell-check doesn;t recognize.

Revision:
"The agony of believing that if your parents knew who you really were they you would be disowned is utterly overwhelming."

I get what you're saying, but the word choice and structure is a litle confusing.

Suggestion: To feel like your parents would disown you if they knew your true identity utterly is overwhelming and painful.

Overall, very well written as your voice shines through beautifully. Just make sure to revuse (I've found that reading it outloud helps you catch things you miss when you read).

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 17:45 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "My dolls weren¿t just pieces of plastic and strips of cloth. To me, they were alive and an extensive part of my life."

Modify Remove


Megan,

Your examples are so sweet! It's so important for young children to have role models--especially older kids--to guide them. I really like the details that your incorporated so that they reader has the full picture. Your examples help to strengthen your passion and show the reader why it is your passion.

However, your tone throughout the paper is very colloquial, with random spurts of formality through verbs, which creates a bit of a discord. For one thing, I would suggest trying to stay away from contractions and either write out both words or just find a new verb to replace it. Also, try to connect your examples throughout the paper. Each paragraph seems disparate from the others; just add some transition sentences and use your thoughts and ideas to connect them.

Revision:

Yours: "My dolls weren¿t just pieces of plastic and strips of cloth. To me, they were alive and an extensive part of my life."

I think these sentences can be connected; the way you used "extensive" sounds awkward; watch the contraction.

Suggestion: To me, my dolls were more than just pieces of plastic and strips of cloth; they were alive and I cared for them as though they were real children.

You definitely know yourself and what you care about in life and your examples show it. Just clean it up and try to connect it better. I've found that reading it outloud to yourself helps you catch things that you miss when reading.

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 17:29 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "A number of my college essays asked me, in some way or another, to define myself, to explain my goals, my turning points, and my pursuits."

ModifyModify RemoveRemove


Megan,

Wow, when I started reading your paper, right from the get-go, I found myself agreeing with you, as I felt the exact same way in high-school and I often felt like everyone else had their "thing" and I was always looking. Great way to incorporate your experience with such a universal struggle. Overall, I like the tone of your paper--formal, yet I still hear your voice. Also, I like your organization as your progress from high-school to today, incorporating your feelings and thoughts throughout.

However, while reading your paper, I often had to stop and re-read sentences; some of your sentences are awkward in word choice and structure. Be careful with how you use adjectives, verbs, and adverbs--I think you sometimes misuse them (as in my revision suggestion), as in, an adjective doing a verb...if that makes sense. Sorry, I know how vague and confusing that sounds, but just make sure in your revision to check grammar. I've found that reading it outloud helps, as you'll probably catch things that just sound awkward. Also, I feel like the change from your search for your passion into your passion for design is a little abrupt and not very fluid. Try to connect how you realized your love for design more within your search and just add some transition.

Revision:
"A number of my college essays asked me, in some way or another, to define myself, to explain my goals, my turning points, and my pursuits."

Firstly, essays don't ask you anything--they're inanimate objects; also, the turning points example doesn't quite fit with the others.

Suggestion: For a number of my college application essays, I was expected to, in some way or another, define myself, my pursuits, and my life goals.

Overall, very well-written and well-supported; just work on revising with a fine-tooth comb!

 

Forum: Project Two Date: Mon Nov 13 2006 17:11 Author: Pande, Chetna  <chetnapande@mail.utexas.edu> Subject: "I had known of my interest in theology before then; however, after only one lesson at G.I.G. I felt this interest being diverted in a way I had not foreseen: I wanted to teach."

Modify Remove


Amanda,

First and foremost, I commend on you on your desire to teach! We definitely need more teachers in society and they need to be more appreciated. Ok, now that I'm done with my brief rant...the organization of your paper is well planned and strenghens your paper. Especially the way that you progressed from your frustration with teaching to your teaching epiphany in 9th grade and how it evolved throughout high school.

However, I do agree with Megan in that sometimes your paper sounds a bit wordy--try to incorporate more action verbs to mix it up a bit. Also, each example that you bring up can potentially strenghen your paper, but I feel like you introduce an example, but kind of leave it hanging; I think if you just expand on your experiences with teaching (especially in GIG when you realized how much you love it), and just explain your reactions more in depth, it would help with cohesion of the paper.

Revision:
Yours: "I had known of my interest in theology before then; however, after only one lesson at G.I.G. I felt this interest being diverted in a way I had not foreseen: I wanted to teach."

The sentence structure and word choice is a little awkward and wordy.

Suggestion: I have always been interested in theology, but after only one lesson at GIG, my interest evolved into an epiphany: I wanted to teach.

Overall, well written, just work on word/verb diversity!