The idea of ¿converting the
natives¿ is by no means unique in Jane Eyre.
In fact, it is so ordinary that I almost overlooked it altogether. From my perspective, that of the minority,
many times dominant religions have this superiority complex which leads them to
believe they are somehow better than others.
Now I do not wish to step on any toes, and I do understand that many
religions do ask their followers to go out and find converts, I do have a big
problem with the disrespect that many show those who do not follow the same
faith as them. In Jane Eyre, St. John presents the
idea of learning ¿Hindustani¿ to go convert Indians to Christianity. This idea is not new, but it does stir up
feelings of resentment in my own culture.
See, the idea of dominance of religions can be traced back to Ruyard Kipling¿s ¿White Man¿s Burden.¿ From a cultural standpoint the idea of any
one believing they are above others is bound to cause animosity, but the
greater question is what leads people to feel this way? There is nothing inherent in all humans that
cries ¿I am better than you because I am Christian/White/Tall/Wealthy/etc.¿ So is the feeling
connected to religions? Or is it
connected to the culture in which the religion is founded? I do not fully know the answers to this
question for Christianity, but I am curios to find out more. Along the lines of the more familiar for me,
Hinduism strongly teaches acceptance of others and respect for others. My connection with my religion has always
stressed this, but perhaps the reason I feel rather strongly about this is
because I grew up in an environment in which I am clearly the minority. Respect is stressed and therefore I believe
my own faith can only become stronger when learning about others beliefs. After all, I don¿t
think I would be able to make it through much of my educational career and this
course even if I did not have that mindset.
With Jane, however, we reach the same idea of imperialism from the
religious standpoint. The winners write
history, and thus a full perspective of any situation is never fully
given. Those who set out to conquer left
us with the images we now have of missionary work to convert those all over the
world. The question that still boggles
me, and I hope open your eyes as well, is why?
Past the idea that some faiths want you to find more followers, and past
the impression that you need to continue what you love, the question is: what
is it that is so wrong with what
people are already following? I hope to
address this question in class today ¿ a mixture of the book, our everyday
lives, and not our everyday lives provides the answer.