|
The New Reading and Writing
Personally, I’ve
always wanted to pursue the ideal of the Renaissance Man -- versatile, skilled
in all areas, and ever-curious -- and so the argument for using hypermedia to
engaged the right brain as well as the left brain in the learning process
appealed to me. Nevertheless, as someone who’s never been a big fan of TV and
knows all too well how easy it is to get sucked into the Internet for mindless
hours, I was a little wary of the suggestion to integrate multimedia so fully
into our education. However, I found the argument for the use of hypermedia
very convincing when I considered some of the classes I’d taken in high school.
Many of my teachers used technology to integrate art, music, history, and video
into our classes, which added greatly to my understanding and feeling of
connection with the texts we were reading. That feeling of connection with a
text was one of the most valuable and rewarding experiences in high school for
me. Whether we viewed paintings from the 14th century while reading The
Canterbury Tales, watched animations to illustrate photosynthesis, or listened
to Allen Ginsberg read "Howl," the use of media made it much easier
to connect to the text and the subsequent connection much stronger. However, like
many of the previous posters, I’m uncomfortable with the idea of hypertext
replacing printed text. I savor books -- there’s something about the physical
experience of holding a book, turning the pages, and feeling the texture of the
paper that simply cannot be replicated by the bright screen of a webpage. When
I read and brainstorm, I like to have a physical copy of the text to hold,
underline, and to scrawl notes on. In a sense, I enjoy interacting with it.
Though hypermedia offers many opportunities for interaction, they are often not
as personal as the experience of physically reading.
Additionally,
though McCorduck lauds "computer-mediated communication[’s] "revolutionary potential" (Bump
19), I feel that, like education of the left brain only, it may have lead to
"the loss of feeling in postmodern culture" (Bump 17). I don’t know
how often I’ve gotten lost in a maze of web pages, only to emerge an hour later
bleary-eyed, or had online conversations with friends
that consist of both parties trying half-heartedly to come up with something to
say. The connections I forge with people are not nearly as strong when I do so
using technology as when we meet face to face. Just as there is something
intrinsically different about reading a book than a webpage, there is something
that I experience when interacting in person that is simply lacking when I
speak to them online or even over the phone. Though multimedia is unarguably a
valuable learning tool and source of information, I feel that it can reduce our
relationships and interactions to less than what they could be.
Here,
essentially, is my understanding of all this: though hypermedia is useful in
its ability to add a feeling of connection to a piece of work, it should not
dismiss the reader’s own personal interaction with the text and cannot replace
his or her own feeling of connection with it.
|